Episode 16, unwritten rules. Choose English or Chinese with the toggle at the top. Includes a readable version, videos, books, and references.第 16 集,讀懂沒寫出來的規則。用上方的切換選擇中文或英文。內容包含可閱讀的完整版、影片、書籍與參考文獻。
Nº 16第 16 集
Mentoring · a field guide帶人 · 實用指南
Unwritten rules
讀懂沒寫出來的規則
Your mentee is a pharmacist who has worked at the hospital for ten years. Last month he presented a plan at the medication safety committee. It added one step for the nurses on one ward. He sent his slides to the ward's head nurse, but he didn't talk with her. The committee chair said, “Let's come back to it next month.”你帶的人是一位藥師,在醫院做了十年。上個月,他在用藥安全委員會提了一個計畫,要一個病房的護理師多做一個步驟。他把簡報寄給了護理長,但沒有當面跟她談。主委說:「這個案子,我們下個月再討論。」
He told you it went well. But in that committee, the chair's words usually mean: we will wait until the nurses agree. He has to take the next step, and the chair won't remind him. You knew that rule. You didn't tell him, because to you it is just how things work here.他跟你說很順利。但在那個委員會,主委這句話通常是說:等護理師那邊同意了再說。下一步要他自己去做,主委不會提醒他。這條規則你知道,但你沒有跟他講,因為對你來說,那只是這裡做事的方式。
Prefer to read instead of watch?想用讀的,不想看影片?
Read the full lesson讀完整內容
Your mentee is a pharmacist. He has worked at the hospital for ten years, and he is very good at his job. Last month he presented a plan at the medication safety committee. The plan was to reduce errors with high-alert medications on one ward. It added one more step for the nurses on that ward. He sent his slides to the ward's head nurse, but he didn't talk with her.
At the meeting, the head nurse said, “We need to discuss this plan with our nurses.” The committee chair said, “Let's come back to it next month.” After the meeting, your mentee told you, “It went well. They'll look at it again next month.”
But you know something he doesn't. In that committee, “Let's come back to it” usually means that the committee will wait until the nurses agree. The chair won't remind him. Your mentee has to take the next step, and the next step is to talk with the head nurse, in person, before the next meeting. You know many rules like that one, but he didn't hear them from you. To you, they aren't rules. They are just how things work here.
First, why didn't he know? A book called The Unspoken Rules is based on interviews with more than five hundred professionals. It describes these rules as things managers expect but don't explain. They are also things the best workers do without noticing. That means us. We follow these rules without thinking, so we forget to explain them.
Your mentee has been here ten years, but the safety plan was his first project outside pharmacy. The book says that when you join a new team or project, you are a learner again. It also says that these rules are passed down from mentor to mentee. If we don't teach them, a mentee may learn them by making mistakes.
In a study of new nurses at a medical center in Taipei, one nurse described this kind of teaching. Her preceptor told her each doctor's habits, and how to work with each one.
Second, how do you find the rules you no longer notice? The book lists several things to learn about a team. Here are four questions you and your mentee can ask together. The first question is: who really decides? Officially, the committee decides. In reality, the committee waits to hear from nursing.
The second question is: whose work will change? Nurses do the extra step, so the head nurse and the nursing department must approve the change. That part is written down. The unwritten part is that the head nurse needs to hear about the plan first, and in person. Her nurses will come to her with questions.
The third question is: what matters most to each person? For the head nurse, it is her nurses' workload and her patients' safety. So she has a fair question: will one more step reduce errors, or just add work? The fourth question is: what can't be said, and where? In some teams, you can talk about another department's problem in the meeting. In others, you raise it in private first.
There is one more thing to notice. The same rule can work differently for your mentee. If you raise a problem, people listen, because you are a senior colleague. If he raises it, they may think that pharmacy is telling nursing how to work. So sometimes the best help is to raise the problem yourself, and say that it was your mentee's idea.
Third, before you teach a rule, decide whether it is worth keeping. The Unspoken Rules ends with a simple test. Teach the rules that help people work better together, and remove the rules that stop some people's ideas from being heard. Talking with the head nurse before the meeting is the first kind. Teach your mentee that rule.
Now imagine a rule in your own unit: an idea is discussed only if a senior person raises it. That rule is the second kind, and your mentee can't change it. When you raise his idea yourself, you help him while the rule still exists. But over time, the rule itself should change. If that rule exists in your unit, your mentee learns it by watching you. So you may be the person who can change it.
Medical educators call this kind of learning the hidden curriculum. It includes the gap between what senior people say and what they do. When you explain a rule, say which kind you think it is. “This rule is worth following, and here's why.” Or: “I don't agree with this rule. Follow it for now, and I'll raise it with the people who can change it.”
This week, before your mentee does something new, ask him which people he'll talk with first, and why. Then tell him one rule he didn't mention, why it exists, and whether you think it is worth keeping.
你帶的人是一位藥師。他在醫院做了十年,工作做得非常好。上個月,他在用藥安全委員會提了一個改善計畫,要降低一個病房高警訊藥品的給藥錯誤。計畫裡,那個病房的護理師要多做一個步驟。他把簡報寄給了那個病房的護理長,但沒有當面跟她談。
會議上,護理長說:「這個計畫,我們要先回單位跟護理師討論。」委員會的主委說:「這個案子,我們下個月再討論。」會後,你帶的人跟你說:「很順利。他們下個月會再看一次。」
但有一件事,你知道,他不知道。在那個委員會,「下個月再討論」通常是說:等護理師那邊同意了再說。主委不會提醒他。下一步,要你帶的人自己去做,也就是下次開會之前,先當面去找護理長談。像這樣的規則,你知道很多,但你沒有跟他講過。對你來說,這些不算規則,只是這裡做事的方式。
第一,他為什麼不知道?有一本書叫《The Unspoken Rules》,意思是「沒有說出口的規則」,是根據五百多位專業人士的訪談寫成的。書裡說,這些規則,是主管希望你做到,但不會特別解釋的事;也是做得最好的人在做,自己卻沒發覺的事。說的就是我們。我們照這些規則做事,已經不用想了,所以也忘了要解釋。
你帶的人在這裡十年了。但這個用藥安全計畫,是他第一次做藥劑部以外的專案。書裡說,當你換到新的團隊或新的專案,你就又變回新人,要重新學。書裡也說,這些規則,是由導師傳給他帶的人。如果我們不教,我們帶的人可能要犯了錯,才學得會。
有一項研究,在台北一家醫學中心訪談新進護理師。其中一位就提到這種教法:她的臨床教師會告訴她每位醫師有什麼習慣,還有要怎麼跟每位醫師配合。
第二,你自己已經察覺不到的規則,要怎麼找出來?書裡列了幾件事,是了解一個團隊時要知道的。這裡有四個問題,你和你帶的人可以一起問。第一個問題:真正做決定的是誰?照規定,是委員會決定。實際上,委員會在等護理那邊的意見。
第二個問題:誰的工作會改變?多出來的步驟是護理師在做,所以要改,就要經過護理長和護理部。這一部分,是有寫下來的。沒寫出來的部分是:護理長需要最先知道這個計畫,而且要當面聽到,因為單位的護理師會來問她。
第三個問題:對每個人來說,最重要的是什麼?對護理長來說,是單位護理師的工作量,還有病人的安全。所以她會有一個很合理的問題:多一個步驟,真的會減少錯誤,還是只是多了工作?第四個問題:什麼話不能講,在哪裡不能講?有些團隊,可以在會議上直接談別的部門的問題。有些團隊,要先私下講。
還有一點要注意:同一條規則,對你帶的人可能不一樣。你提出一個問題,大家會聽,因為說話的是資深同事。他提出來,大家可能會聽成:藥劑部在教護理部怎麼做事。所以有時候,最好的幫忙,是由你把問題提出來,然後講清楚,這是你帶的人的想法。
第三,在你教一條規則之前,先決定它值不值得留下來。《The Unspoken Rules》最後給了一個簡單的判斷方法:如果一條規則讓大家合作得更好,就要教;如果一條規則讓某些人的想法沒機會被聽見,就要拿掉。開會前先去找護理長談,是第一種。這一條,要教給你帶的人。
再想像一下,你的單位有這樣一條規則:一個想法,要由資深的人提出來,大家才會討論。這是第二種,而且這條規則,你帶的人改不了。由你幫他把想法提出來,是在這條規則還在的時候先幫他。但長期來說,這條規則本身要改。如果你的單位有這條規則,你帶的人是看著你學會的。所以能改這條規則的人,可能就是你。
醫學教育界把這種看著學來的東西,叫做「潛在課程」。其中包括資深的人嘴上說的,跟實際做的之間的落差。你在跟他解釋一條規則的時候,說出你覺得它是哪一種。「這一條值得遵守,原因是這樣。」或者:「這一條我不同意。你先照著做,我會去跟能改的人提。」
這禮拜,在你帶的人做一件新的事之前,問他打算先找哪些人談,為什麼。然後告訴他一條他沒提到的規則:為什麼會有這條規則,還有你覺得它值不值得留下來。
Test yourself on this episode測驗一下這一集
A few quick questions, to help you remember this. The options are shuffled, so it is worth trying again later.幾個小問題,幫你把重點記牢。選項每次都會重新排列,之後再測一次還是有用。
Take two minutes to reflect
花兩分鐘,回顧一下
These questions are part of the lesson. Answering them helps it stick, and it shows us whether the series is working. Under two minutes, all on this page.這幾個問題也是課程的一部分。回答它們能幫你記得更牢,也讓我們知道這個系列有沒有用。不到兩分鐘,直接在這頁填就好。
He has been here ten years. On this project, he is a learner again.
他在這裡十年了。在這個專案上,他又是新人。
The safety plan was his first project outside pharmacy. The book The Unspoken Rules describes unwritten rules as things managers expect but don't explain. It says the best workers follow them without noticing. So a mentor can know a rule well and still not teach it.
這個用藥安全計畫,是他第一次做藥劑部以外的專案。《The Unspoken Rules》這本書說,這些規則,是主管希望你做到,但不會特別解釋的事;做得最好的人照著做,自己卻沒發覺。所以一個導師可能很熟一條規則,卻還是沒有教。
We follow unwritten rules without thinking. So we forget to explain them.
我們照這些規則做事,已經不用想了。所以我們也忘了要解釋。
When you cross a border, ask what is not allowed. When you enter a country, ask how people there do things. When you enter a home, ask what must not be said.
入竟而問禁,入國而問俗,入門而問諱。
The Book of Rites (《禮記》) tells a visitor to ask about the local rules first. Your mentee's plan would change the work of another department, and he did not know there was anything to ask. You knew the answer.《禮記》說,到了別人的地方,先問清楚那裡的規矩。你帶的人提的計畫,會改變別的部門的工作,他卻不知道有什麼要問。答案你是知道的。
Which line helps your mentee find the rule?
哪一句,能幫你帶的人找到那條規則?
There are three pairs. In each pair, both lines are things an experienced mentor might say to a mentee. Neither line is wrong, but one of them helps more. Read both lines before you choose.
這裡有三組。每一組的兩句,都是有經驗的導師可能會對你帶的人說的話。兩句都沒有錯,但有一句比較有幫助。兩句都看完再選。
Read each situation. Which line would you say?
看完每一個情況,你會說哪一句?
Which line helps your mentee learn the unwritten rule better?哪一句,比較能幫你帶的人學會那條沒寫出來的規則?
Before you teach a rule, decide whether it's worth keeping.
教一條規則之前,先決定它值不值得留下來。
Some unwritten rules help people work better together. Talking with the head nurse before the meeting is one of them, so teach it. Other rules stop some people's ideas from being heard. If a rule like that exists in your unit, your mentee can't change it, and he learns it by watching you. You may be the person who can change it.
有些沒寫出來的規則,讓大家合作得更好。開會前先去找護理長談,就是這一種,要教。有些規則,讓某些人的想法沒機會被聽見。如果你的單位有這樣的規則,你帶的人改不了,而且他是看著你學會的。能改這條規則的人,可能就是你。
When you raise your mentee's idea yourself, you help him while the rule still exists. But over time, the rule itself should change.
由你幫他把想法提出來,是在這條規則還在的時候先幫他。但長期來說,這條規則本身要改。
- 1
Say the rule.把規則說出來。
Use plain words, and say where it applies. “In that committee, ‘Let's come back to it next month’ usually means: wait until the nurses agree.”用白話講,也講清楚是在哪裡適用。「在那個委員會,『下個月再討論』通常是說:等護理師那邊同意了再說。」
- 2
Say why the rule exists.說為什麼會有這條規則。
The head nurse needs to hear about a change first because her nurses will come to her with questions. If your mentee knows the reason, he can use the rule on another ward.護理長需要最先知道有這個改變,因為單位的護理師會來問她。你帶的人知道原因,到了別的病房也用得上。
- 3
Say whether you think it's worth keeping.說你覺得它值不值得留下來。
“This rule is worth following, and here's why.” Or: “I don't agree with this rule. Follow it for now, and I'll raise it with the people who can change it.”「這一條值得遵守,原因是這樣。」或者:「這一條我不同意。你先照著做,我會去跟能改的人提。」
- 4
If his idea won't be heard, raise it yourself.他的想法沒機會被聽見,就由你來提。
If a rule in your unit means his idea won't be heard, raise the idea yourself and say it was his. Then raise the rule with the people who can change it.如果你的單位有一條規則,會讓他的想法沒機會被聽見,就由你把想法提出來,並且講清楚這是他的想法。然後去跟能改的人提這條規則。
Teaching rules does not mean deciding quickly which rules are good and which are bad. A rule may seem to stop ideas from being heard. But it may have a reason that you don't know yet, such as a problem the team had in the past. Before you tell your mentee that a rule should change, ask the people who follow it why the rule exists. Then say what you think.
教規則,不是要你很快決定哪些規則好、哪些規則不好。一條規則,看起來可能讓別人的想法沒機會被聽見。但它背後可能有你還不知道的原因,像是這個團隊以前出過的問題。在你跟你帶的人說一條規則該改之前,先問問照著它做的人,為什麼會有這條規則。然後再說你的看法。
Watch out for要留意的地方
- raising his ideas for him so often that he stops raising them himself太常幫他提想法,結果他自己不再提了
- saying you disagree with a rule, and then not raising it with the people who can change it說你不同意一條規則,之後卻沒有去跟能改的人提
- treating questions from another department as a way of saying no, when they are fair questions about that department's own work把別的部門提出的問題當成反對,其實那是跟他們自己工作有關的合理問題
Before your mentee does something new在他做新的事之前
Your mentee is about to do something new. Complete this form, email it to yourself, and bring it to your next meeting with your mentee.你帶的人就要做一件新的事了。填一填,寄給自己,下次跟他談的時候帶著。
A rule they may not know yet他可能還不知道的規則
What you will say about the rule談到這條規則,你會說的那一句
Your note你的小抄
Three short talks to go deeper
三支值得一看的短講
Books and evidence
推薦書與實證
Evidence and further reading實證與參考文獻
Listed in English, as published.參考文獻依原文列出,未翻譯。
Twenty-six episodes, one relationship
二十六集,一段師徒關係
From the first meeting to the day they no longer need you. One step a week.
從第一次見面,到他不再需要你的那一天。每週一步。
Here for patients · Here for each other
為了病人,也為了彼此